Source TOI
CHICAGO / NEW DELHI — Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi has criticized the Narendra Modi government’s foreign policy, arguing that India has stepped back from major geopolitical negotiations while Pakistan plays a mediating role between the United States and Iran.
Speaking during an interactive session with students and faculty at the University of Chicago on Thursday—moderated by Professor Robert Pape—Gandhi expressed concern that New Delhi has failed to leverage its established relationships with Washington, Tehran, and Moscow to exert diplomatic influence amid heightened tensions in the Gulf.
“By our size, our history and our relationships, we should be involved in these global conversations. But frankly, India has become a side player. We have stepped back from the stage,” Gandhi said during the session and in a subsequent post on X. Expressing surprise at Islamabad’s involvement in the peace talks, he added, “I’m pretty shocked that Pakistan is busy negotiating with the Iranians and the Americans, and India’s just looking”.
Gandhi also questioned the effectiveness of relying on personal rapport with world leaders to drive foreign policy. “Friendship is not the point. Who gives a damn about friendship? Do you really think that geopolitics is going to work because the guy is your friend?” he remarked, arguing that leaders act based on their respective economic systems and national structures rather than personal ties.
Recalling India’s founding leadership in the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) following Independence, the Congress leader stated that India historically maintained an independent geopolitical stance guided by its own national interests and urged New Delhi to reclaim that stature in an emerging multipolar global order. He further noted that conflicts in West Asia directly impact Indian citizens through economic pressures.
In response to a question from a Pakistani participant regarding the possibility of improving bilateral relations between New Delhi and Islamabad, Gandhi reiterated that any dialogue remains contingent on an end to cross-border terrorism. “It is impossible for us to accept our innocent people being murdered and have a conversation with Pakistan. So, the moment that stops, a conversation can potentially begin,” he stated.
Meanwhile, the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) pushed back against Gandhi’s remarks made during his US visit, criticizing him for attacking the government on foreign soil. On the broader issue of West Asia mediation, External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar had previously stated during an all-party meeting on the crisis that India does not seek to act as a broker nation in global geopolitics, while Prime Minister Narendra Modi has maintained that India’s efforts remain focused on de-escalation, dialogue, and diplomacy.
